SNARE DRUM - SNARE WIRE COMPARISON

James Walker
first posted April, 2004, last updated October, 2005


What follows is a comparison of several different makes and models of snare wires, all recorded on the same snare drum. The snare drum was a drum I built, with the following specs:

The drum was recorded with an SM57 on the batter side, a Marshall MXL 2001 on the snare side, recorded through a Mackie 1202, and edited in ProTools Free on a Macintosh computer, with no EQ or effects processing applied.

Three mp3 files are presented for each set of wires: one from the batter side mic', one from the snare side mic', and one mixing these two tracks. Each track includes individual snare hits, a roll, a short and simple groove, and in some cases, several strikes of my 12" rack tom (included for the purposes of comparing sympathetic vibrations), although I've decided not to add them to more recent samples - all they seemed to demonstrate was that my 12" tom needs work. No retuning of either head took place. Where applicable, the snares were recorded twice: once at a looser tension, and once again at a tighter tension.

Remember - snare wires are only one of the elements that contribute to a snare drum's overall sound. Head choices, shell material and dimensions, bearing edge shape, tuning, and snare beds (etc.) all are factors. This page only demonstrates how these wires sound on this particular drum - there's no guarantee that they'll sound the same on your drum. I simply hope to provide the opportunity to do an "A/B" comparison of how certain snare wires compare, all other things being equal.

(For a FAQ page regarding these comparisons, please click here.)

Special thanks to Eric Sooy at Black Swamp Percussion, and Mike Z, for submitting snare wires to be included in this comparison.

Black Swamp Canopus DW
Fat Cat generic 42-strand modified 12-strand
Grover Ludwig Noble and Cooley
Pearl Premier Puresound
Rhythm Tech Sonor Tama
Yamaha

Tempus 6x14 fibreglass snare - snares off
batter mic'snareside mic'-


Black Swamp DynamicX DST1420 (20-strand steel)
DynamicX DST1420, looser tension
(Aug. 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
DynamicX DST1420, tighter tension
(Aug. 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Black Swamp DynamicX DPB1420 (20-strand phosphor bronze)
DynamicX DPB1420, looser tension
(Oct. 2005)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
DynamicX DPB1420, tighter tension
(Oct. 2005)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Canopus
Canopus non-plated wires, looser tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Canopus non-plated wires, tighter tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix

Canopus chrome-plated wires, looser tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Canopus chrome-plated wires, tighter tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


DW
DW 20-strand "TruTone" wires, looser tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
DW 20-strand "TruTone" wires, tighter tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Fat Cat
Fat Cat snares, loose tension (tight middle section)
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Fat Cat snares, tight tension (tight middle section)
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


generic 42-strand
42-strand wire snares, loose tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
42-strand wire snares, tighter tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


12-strand (modified Canopus bronze, not commercially available)
12-strand wire snares, loose tension
(Oct. 2005)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
12-strand wire snares, tighter tension
(Oct. 2005)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Grover (cable)
Grover "Club Bright" 15-strand snares, loose tension
(October 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Grover "Club Bright" 15-strand snares, tight tension
(October 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix

Grover "Jazz Bright" 15-strand snares, loose tension
(October 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Grover "Jazz Bright" 15-strand snares, tight tension
(October 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix

Grover "Stadium Bright" 15-strand snares, loose tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Grover "Stadium Bright" 15-strand snares, tight tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Ludwig
Ludwig "Snappy Snare" 20-strand wires, looser tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Ludwig "Snappy Snare" 20-strand wires, tighter tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Noble & Cooley
Noble & Cooley "Cam Action" Snare Wires, loose tension
(May 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Noble & Cooley "Cam Action" Snare Wires, tighter tension
(May 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Pearl
Pearl 24-strand wire snares, loose tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Pearl 24-strand wire snares, tight tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Premier
Premier chrome 20-strand wires, looser tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Premier chrome 20-strand wires, tighter tension
(July 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Puresound
Puresound "Blaster" snares, loose tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Puresound "Blaster" snares, tigher tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix

Puresound Custom P1420, loose tension
(May 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Puresound Custom P1420, tighter tension
(May 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix

Puresound Equalizer snares, loose tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Puresound Equalizer snares, tight tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Rhythm Tech
Rhythm Tech Active Snare System
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Sonor
Sonor 24-strand wire snares, loose tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Sonor 24-strand wire snares, tight tension
(April 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix


Tama
Tama Starclassic Bell Brass, 20-strand, loose tension
(May 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Tama Starclassic Bell Brass, 20-strand, tighter tension
(May 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix

Tama Starclassic Chrome Plated, 20-strand, loose tension
(May 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Tama Starclassic Chrome Plated, 20-strand, tighter tension
(May 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix



Yamaha
Yamaha Chrome Plated, 20-strand, loose tension
(October 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix
Yamaha Chrome Plated, 20-strand, tighter tension
(October 2004)
batter mic'snareside mic'mix

www.malletjazz.com